New York City has made its position clear: if an employer uses AI to help make a decision about a worker and that decision is unlawful, the employer is responsible. Saying the software made the call is not a defense. The point comes from a Law.com expert opinion piece on the city's AI enforcement position.
What changed
According to the article, the city has reaffirmed that employers must follow anti-discrimination and worker-protection laws when they use automated systems. The piece frames the issue as a simple question: who is legally responsible when an algorithm contributes to an unlawful result? The city's answer is the employer.
Who it affects
Any employer in New York City that uses automated tools in employment decisions is touched by this. The article speaks of AI becoming more embedded in those decisions. The message for a business owner is that buying or using a tool from someone else does not move the legal risk onto that tool or its maker.
What audits and review can and cannot do
The article notes that audits and human review can help. An audit is a check of how a tool behaves. Human review means a person looks at the tool's output before a decision is made. But the article says these steps do not replace legal compliance. Doing them is useful, yet they do not make an unlawful decision lawful.
What to do
- Find out which software your business uses to screen, rank or manage workers.
- Know how each tool is used in real decisions, not just what it promises.
- Keep a person involved in reviewing results, as one part of a wider approach.
- Treat audits as support for compliance, not a substitute for it.
What is not known yet
The full article sits behind a subscription, so only the summary is available here. Details such as specific enforcement steps, penalties or new guidance are not in the material. Employers who want to know how the position applies to their own tools should read the full piece or ask a labor lawyer.
The takeawayIf your business uses software to screen or manage workers, the legal risk is yours, so learn how those tools are used and do not rely on audits alone.