1. News
  2. Everyday tech
  3. Safety · Seniors
Safety · Seniors1 min read

Medical alert devices with fall detection: what AARP's tests found

AARP tested more than 30 medical alert devices with staged falls. Medical Guardian came out on top, and fall detection usually costs about $10 more a month.

By the Dashline deskSource: AARP
Medical alert devices with fall detection: what AARP's tests found
Photo: Lifecirclehealthservices, CC BY-SA 4.0

AARP put more than 30 medical alert devices through lab test falls and named Medical Guardian the best overall system with fall detection. All three of its devices passed. Each caught at least 10 of 12 test falls, while AARP counts nine of 12 as passing.

How the tests worked

AARP's Smart Picks team worked with older adult testers and designed four lab test falls. It drew on advice from occupational therapists, nurses and physical therapists. Fall detection is built into the wearable device. It senses the movements that come with a fall and connects you to a staffed 24/7 monitoring center, which can send emergency help.

  • Medical Guardian tested three devices: MGHome (at home), Guardian Flex (mobile) and MGMove (smartwatch).
  • Both mobile devices passed GPS location tests, including at a grocery store, a hardware store and an airport lot.
  • Fall detection usually costs about $10 more per month.
  • The smartwatch audio was sometimes muffled.

What is not known

The article text provided covers only the top pick. The other five systems in the list are not described here. Base plan prices are not given either. AARP says one Medical Guardian device aced the test, but the text does not say which one. An occupational therapist quoted in the review says fall detection is not 100 percent accurate, though it is highly reliable. AARP may earn commissions from affiliate links.

The takeaway

Fall detection costs extra, so check how a device did in real fall tests before paying for it.

More articles

You should really read these.

Next step

Let’s talk