AI is trimming what online marketplaces spend to run, not what they charge. Who keeps those savings will shape fees and prices for sellers and shoppers.
Online marketplaces are using AI to cut their costs, but the fees they charge are barely moving. Etsy kept $22.80 of every $100 buyers spent in late 2024, and AI has barely moved that. The savings are landing in cost lines underneath, such as support and fraud. A Finance Monthly column by a marketplace adviser argues the real contest is who keeps them.
A take rate is the cut a marketplace keeps from each sale. It works like a price. Sellers compare it across platforms, regulators watch it, and raising it is slow and public. Costs are different. Nobody announces a smaller support queue. The author calls the result the take-rate squeeze: the fee holds steady while AI presses cost out underneath, and the savings go to the platform, its sellers, its buyers or a new middleman.
Marketing is the biggest controllable cost. Etsy spent $856.6 million on it in 2024 against $2.81 billion in revenue, about 30.5% by the author's math. AI makes ad creative cheaper. But rivals bid in the same auctions, so much of the saving on buying attention goes back to the ad platforms.
Amazon's $10 billion figure is its own estimate, based on an internal measure with a seven-day attribution window. The gain shows up as more purchases, not lower costs. The author also warns that an assistant that answers questions directly may show fewer paid listings. That would eat into ad revenue, though it is the author's inference, not Amazon's.
Support savings can be fake. A bot that makes a guest give up does not save money. The cost moves into refunds, bad reviews and lost customers. Fraud has a limit too, since fraudsters use the same AI tools to write fake listings and messages. The line gets cheaper per order, not cheap.
Sellers may not see lower fees even as the platform's costs fall. Buyers may see better search and faster support. Platforms keep whatever margin they do not pass on. The column's example is illustrative: a marketplace with $1 billion in sales and a 15% take rate has $150 million to cover all its costs.
The article is cut off before it covers disputes, so the full list of cost lines is not clear. For now, the thing to track is whether fees stay flat while a marketplace's costs keep falling.
If you sell on or run a marketplace, watch the cost lines AI trims, because the savings may go to the platform, sellers or buyers.
Some scams now pass every bank security check, and UK losses from payments that victims approve themselves reached £576.4m in 2025.
Read more: Fraud that passes every security check is a growing problemA leaked EU draft would make AI shopping helpers ask for fresh approval when they are paid to push a deal. Shoppers and sellers could see more prompts.
Read more: EU draft law would make AI shopping helpers ask before some purchasesVisa tested 22 AI models on mock purchases. They failed 43% of the time, and in over half of those failures the AI still went ahead and bought.
Read more: AI shopping assistants flunked 43% of Visa's buying tests
